*Intactivism Alert; I feel strongly against the tradition of circumcising infant males and this post conveys this and so those who feel otherwise might be offended*
"Our children do not *belong* to us; they are not our possessions, nor our property (as are cars, furniture and handbags). We are entrusted with their care. There is a deep and profound difference." ~Lana Zimprich
When I was young I thought that circumcising boys was the ‘norm’ and didn’t question it until much later. I even remember fearing giving birth to a boy and having to stand by and watch this obviously painful procedure being done to my baby. Like many, I was led to believe that it was medically necessary and even culturally preferable, until I researched more into it and learned otherwise.
My research brought me to face many myths surrounding circumcision, most of which are deeply ingrained in our culture despite having the medical ‘benefits’ long discounted by even the medical associations that were initially promoting them. Soon it became apparent to me that it is a grossly unnecessary procedure that really has no tangible benefits other than it makes men’s genitals more appealing to some people. It is essentially a cultural tradition that has been parading as a medical necessity when it is really elective cosmetic surgery. Once I learned this truth, I decided even before I knew I was even carrying a son that I would leave him as he was born: perfectly healthy and whole.
Today many parents still practice this form of genital mutilation (as stated according to the Canadian Children's Rights Council) due to misinformation about its implications and the mistaken belief that it is preferable socially. If given the appropriate information, I believe more parents would chose to keep their sons intact because in my mind no conscious parent would alter their children in such a profound way if they knew the truth. I cannot fathom how people rationalise taking away a functioning part of a person’s anatomy without their consent, especially if they were made aware of how unnecessary it is.
That being said, here are some of the reasons why I chose to keep my son intact apart from the obvious lack of medical need:
“It’s Easy to Care For” People mistakenly believe the circumcised penis is cleaner because smegma is reduced and that an intact penis requires constant cleaning from birth onwards. The fact is throughout childhood there is really no need to wash since little smegma is produced and forcibly retracting it before it separates naturally, usually by the end of puberty, will cause tearing and can become infected which might require circumcision to correct as a last resort. Besides, smegma is actually beneficial, helping keep the glans moist and facilitating sexual intercourse by acting as a lubricant. Once the foreskin is retractable, simply washing it with warm water while in the shower is all it requires. Quite simple really!
“It Supports Individualism” Many seem to think that a circumcised penis is preferred by women and that an intact one is primed for ridicule, especially in the ‘locker room’ scenario. First of all, it is taboo to be caught observing another man’s privates, and second it’s essentially inconsequential, never mind extremely personal how a man looks naked. It is up to each individual what they prefer. Women don’t necessarily desire a circumcised penis over an intact one, just like how some prefer certain body types, and to generalise what women like is inappropriate. Genitalia, like any physical feature, can take many forms even in its natural intact state.
Instead of changing a child’s appearance in such a private way to assuage the fear of them being alienated by their peers or potential spouses, it would be far more positive to teach them to accept bodily diversity and to build up their self-esteem to handle such teasing and bullying in a mature manner. Our youth today face many self-esteem issues that have at their roots the belief that they are not good enough so let us prove to them that they are by accepting their differences from birth onwards.
“It is the Norm” According to recent studies, Canada has a 31.9% circumcision rate, meaning 68.9% of new baby boys are intact. Currently, Alberta is the highest province with approximately 44% circumcised and Nova Scotia is the lowest with only 6%. The circumcision rate for males worldwide is about 15%. Meaning most men are left intact making it the norm rather than being circumcised, despite what many believe.
“It Upholds Children’s Rights” Unlike adult circumcision where the patient is making a personal choice to have himself circumcised, most are performed on children who are not capable of making an informed decision. They are having a functioning part of their body permanently removed for cosmetic reasons by someone outside of themselves. If this would happen to an adult, their rights would be considered violated. When we choose to keep our sons intact, we are giving them power over their own bodies and telling them that we respect them as they are. We are teaching them to honour themselves and to take responsibility for caring for their bodies. It is their right to be able to make decisions over their appearances, especially if they are to be permanent. If my son wants to be circumcised once he’s reached the age of majority, I will support him. It’s HIS body after all. However he will have pay for the cosmetic surgery like any other consenting adult.
“It Circumvents Early Trauma” Some erroneously believe that infants don't feel pain or have working memories but according to recent studies in developmental psychology and neuroscience, this myth is discounted completely. Not only do they feel pain and at least remember it on a subconscious level, they feel it more acutely than adults because their brains are not yet developed enough to rationalize their experiences. Some studies even suggest that early painful experiences lead to a change in their fragile central nervous system and affect their neurochemistry.
Parents of circumcised boys sometimes claim that their child was unaffected by the trauma due to lack of crying and simply lay there with their eyes wide open, or even sleeping during the procedure. The reactions they’re describing are exactly that of what a typical human in severe shock would exhibit. The process of psychological dissociation from trauma occurs when the experience goes beyond the coping abilities of the victim. Infants may exhibit: no crying at all or excessive crying, little emotional expression, strong preference to face outward when being carried afterwards, lack of focused eye contact, chronic postures or movements, cold and clammy hands/feet, restlessness, hyper vigilance, AMNESIA, tremors, fainting or dizziness, pupils fixed very large or small, dryness in eyes, dry mouth, tight jaws, difficulty breathing, and digestive upsets. In short; they are so traumatised that they essentially shut down. This can affect the parent-child bond as well as cause breastfeeding issues.
This whole scenario can be avoided by allowing our sons to remain whole and not subjecting them to surgery mere days after birth, when they need our protection the most.
"I believe no man would allow his beloved son to be circumcised if he were in touch with the terror he experienced during his own." John Breeding
“It Contributes to Ending All Genital Mutilation” Female circumcision is typically viewed as more horrific than male circumcision because it is usually done under unhygienic conditions rather than in a hospital however, both are classed as genital mutilation by the International Coalition for Genital Integrity. Both forms of circumcision remove functional, normal tissue, cause extreme pain, permanently disfigure the genitals, and permanently damage the sexual response. And in most cultures where female circumcision is performed, male circumcision is also performed with equally unhygienic instruments. By choosing to keep our sons intact, we are sending the message that we no longer support this horrific tradition and eventually it will become a thing of the past, for both genders. People have the right to keep the bodies they were born with unaltered.
Those were some of the reasons I chose to keep my son intact, minus the medical reasons that could be found in the links provided below. I feel strongly for preserving children’s rights as people and ensuring they keep their genital integrity is one of them.
Here are some wonderful links on the subject: